About Us

In 2024, Justin Stark founded Pontotoc Insurance Agency with a clear mission: to empower individuals and families in our community and beyond to confidently navigate retirement and life's transitions. Recognizing a need for more personalized guidance in the Medicare space, Justin partnered with his childhood friend, Warren Boatwright. Together, they are building Pontotoc Insurance Agency into a trusted resource for insurance and retirement planning, supported by a dedicated team.

We understand that navigating Medicare, retirement, and life's changes can be complex. That's why we're committed to providing clear, unbiased, and personalized advice to help you make informed decisions about your healthcare and financial future. We believe everyone deserves access to quality, affordable coverage and peace of mind, and we strive to simplify the process for our clients.

We offer a comprehensive range of services, including retirement planning, Medicare plan comparisons (Medicare Advantage, Medigap/ Supplement, and Prescription Drug Plans), and a full suite of life and health insurance solutions. Our team of licensed and experienced agents is here to answer your questions, explain your options in plain language, and help you find the best plan or strategy to meet your unique needs, health, financial goals, and budget.

As a veteran-owned and operated company, we are committed to the values of attention to detail, perseverance, and continuous improvement to enhance your customer experience.

At Pontotoc Insurance Agency, we believe your financial security should be a top priority, especially as you approach and enjoy your retirement years. We are proud to serve our community and are dedicated to being your trusted partners in navigating the world of Medicare and beyond.